1997
Scott Gruber - DB - 2nd team
1998
Bobby Hendry - RB - 1st team
Matt Mechling - DL - 2nd team to add te
1999
Jason Kennedy - RB - 1st team
Bill Liber - QB - 2nd team
2000
Chris Coast - LB - SM
Brek Gerber - DB - SM
Jared Gulling WR - 1st team
Jamar Quincy - QB - 2nd teamer
2001
Jared Gulling - WR - 2nd team
Curt Lukens - LB - 1st team
Brad Reifsnyder - QB - 1st team
Bart Sparhawk - LB - SM
2002
Pete Foradas - DL - 2nd team
Curt Lukens LB - 1st team
Jim Pope - LB - SM
Chris Teter - OL - 1st team h
2003
Jon Andrews - OL - 1st team
Sam Cerreta - QB - 2nd team
Chad Coyle - DB - SM
Alex Ramsey - RB - 1st team
Kyle Watts - DL - 1st team
Mike Wright - RB - SM
2005
Kyle Robbins - DE - 2nd teamk
Associated Press Division I All-Ohio Honors
2008
Erick Howard - RB - Ohio's Mr. Football
Dom Boyle - OL - 1st team
A.J. Sarbaugh - K - 2nd team
Tim Hartzell - LB - 2nd team
Jeff Meek - DB - SM
2007
Matt Wakulchik - WR - 1st team
James Georgiades - DL - 1st team
Kevin Dahl - LB - 2nd team
Dominic Boyle - OL - SM
Jared Wackerly - QB - SM
Erick Howard - RB - SM
2006
Ken Staudinger - DL - 1st team
Matt Wakulchik - WR - 2nd team
Under coach Don Hertler Jr (1996 - present)
2009
Erick Howard - RB - Ohio's Mr. Football
Mark Wiley - OL - 3rd team
Jordan Witt - LB - SM